Receive the latest mybusiness news
Copyright © 2020 MOMENTUMMEDIA

Illegal contracts giving employers false security

Adam Zuchetti
Adam Zuchetti
19 June 2017 1 minute readShare

Employers can be giving themselves a false sense of security by drawing up employment contracts and workplace agreements that actually breach the law.

That is the experience of specialist SME lawyer Mark Gardiner of Teddington Legal, who says this is a reality for some employers who falsely believe their agreement trumps any pre-existing employment legislation.

“We’ve seen agreements that are unlawful. I read one just the other day, which said it would be a ground for dismissal if someone had an issue under the Mental Health Act. That would be straight out discrimination. Thats clearly a health issue and you cant discriminate based on someones health,” explains Mark while speaking on the My Business Podcast.


According to Mark, it is important for any employer drawing up such agreements to know – and understand – what their legal obligations are, and then tailor the employment contract to suit the needs of the business under those obligations.

“Its not like, say, a building contract where you need to specify everything. Employment relationships are governed by the act, but the Fair Work Act and what are called the National Employment Standards. So those pieces of legislation and regulation set out how many annual leave [days] youre entitled to have, how many personal carers leave days, what are the maternity leave provisions [etc],” he says.


“To some extent, if theyre not in the employment agreement, its not so important because they are the law anyway.”

Employer rights and responsibilities can be quite a gray area for many, such as where the line sits between a business need and anti-discrimination rules.
Some aspects can be more straightforward, such as LGBTI awareness in business.

Others, however, can be either very subtle or simply downright confusing. The diverse range of articles on the My Business site demonstrate just how far this confusion can reach. For example:

What can and can’t you ask in a job interview? 
Can you sack a worker for getting a tattoo?
• Where does an employee’s mental health fit with anti-discrimination as well as health and safety workplace requirements? 



According to Mark, the simplest thing employers can do is to research the relevant state and federal government website for information on their obligations, or seek the expertise of an employment lawyer.

Mark has plenty more insights into the various legal queries and conundrums of people management and HR – including unfair dismissal, immigration and more – on the My Business Podcast below:

Illegal contracts giving employers false security
mybusiness logo
Adam Zuchetti
Adam Zuchetti

Adam Zuchetti is the editor of My Business, and has steered the publication’s editorial direction since early 2016. 

The two-time Publish Awards finalist has an extensive journalistic career across business, property and finance, including a four-year stint in the UK. Email Adam at [email protected]

Leave a Comment

Latest poll

Should the government make further amendments to JobKeeper?